Weighing in on an earlier discussion surrounding OFHEO’s HPI home price measure versus the S&P Case/Shiller index numbers, Freddie Mac’s chief economist Frank Nothaft jumps into the debate with a simple “can’t we all just get along?” message:

Each of [the different housing measures] has its own advantages and disadvantages, though, and a deeper look into the numbers reveals a clear message: home price appreciation has weakened sharply, but with significant differences across regions and metro markets.

Nothaft characterizes measures used by the NAR and the Commerce Dept. as useful for near-term price trending, but limited for longer term comparison because the measures are vulnerable to market shifts (i.e., more high-end homes sold one month versus the previous). Nothaft argues that the more complex measures (the Case/Shiller, HPI, and Freddie’s own CMHPI) make an “apples-to-apples” comparison easier by using a repeat-sales methodology, but that each has its own separate drawbacks: the HPI measures don’t capture movement outside of the conforming market, while the Case/Shiller numbers don’t offer nearly as broad coverage. However you slice it, Nothaft says, the market messages and risks are clear:

The differences between the various house price measures … should not overshadow the similarities. All show that national price growth has shifted down from the double-digit gains of 2004-2005 to something near zero, with several markets down from a year ago … While a steady job market and growing national economy may help limit the downside risks to housing prices, several risks – the elevated levels of homes for sale, recent increases in mortgage rates, and rising foreclosures of subprime borrowers – point to continued weakness in the months ahead.

Most Popular Articles

Realtors expect these to be the 10 hottest housing markets for the next 3-5 years

Here are the 10 housing markets that the National Association of Realtors expects to the hottest in the nation in the next three to five years.

Dec 11, 2019 By

Latest Articles

Gateway First Bank makes two key hires

Gateway First Bank made back-to-back announcements this week regarding two key hires. The bank welcomed Joell Maddox as director of treasury services and Thomas Ramm joined as chief investment officer.

Dec 12, 2019 By
3d rendering of a row of luxury townhouses along a street

Log In

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account? Please