Politics & Money

To rent or to own? That is the question

If you’re trying to measure the costs of homeownership versus the cost of renting a home, there’s an official tool to help you. The Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland released a Rent or Buy Calculator that runs an internal simulation of cost scenarios, for both renting and owning a home, based on the information you put in about your home and mortgage. From the data, it will tell you how much, if at all, you will financially gain from owning a home versus renting. Its an interesting tool, but I’m not convinced it’s comprehensive. I found a home for sale online and used the calculator as if I planned to purchase the house under the terms of a HECM Saver (I know HECM is only for reverse mortgages, but I wanted to see if a .01% down payment would affect my stats :-). I found a gorgeous three bedroom, three bathroom house located in north Dallas and entered my respective information. The calculator told me I had a 95% chance of financially gaining $81,522 from buying a $510,000 home at .01% down payment versus renting a $1,300 property over the same time period. 30-year, fixed rate at 4.09% anyone? But what the calculator doesn’t measure is the golden phrase most mortgage experts are now living by: my ability to pay (or lack thereof). The calculator doesn’t know I am a 22-years-old rambunctious spender that’s living paycheck-to-paycheck. If I hadn’t found the cheapest duplex in Dallas, granted at the expense of a dishwasher and central air, I would probably still be mooching off my parents. So while the Cleveland Fed has produced a useful tool to measure the best potential you have in owning a home, take the disclosure to heart: “This calculator is for informational purposes only. The results should not be interpreted as investment advice.” After all, the only reason I used the calculator was because it’s free. Write to Christine Ricciardi.

Most Popular Articles

Spouse of Quicken Loans executive sues AIME’s Anthony Casa for defamation

Theresa Niemiec, wife of Quicken Loans Executive Vice President Austin Niemiec, has filed a defamation lawsuit against Anthony Casa, CEO of the Association of Independent Mortgage Experts, for comments he made about her in a video message that he filmed and sent to her husband and others in the mortgage industry.

Jul 12, 2020 By
3d rendering of a row of luxury townhouses along a street

Log In

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account? Please