At the end of the second quarter there were 7,443,580 residential properties that were seriously underwater — where the combined loan amount secured by the property is at least 25% higher than the property’s estimated market value — representing 13.3% of all properties with a mortgage, according to the second quarter report from RealtyTrac.
The second quarter underwater numbers were up from 7,341,922 seriously underwater homes representing 13.2% of all homes with a mortgage in the previous quarter — making Q2 the second consecutive quarter with a slight increase in both the number and share of seriously underwater properties — but were down from 9,074,449 seriously underwater properties representing 17.2% of all homes with a mortgage in the second quarter of 2015.
The number and share of seriously underwater homes peaked in the second quarter of 2012 at 12,824,729 seriously homes representing 28.6% of all homes with a mortgage.
“Slowing home price appreciation in 2015 has resulted in the share of seriously underwater properties plateauing at about 13% of all properties with a mortgage,” said Daren Blomquist, vice president at RealtyTrac. “However, the share of homeowners with the double-whammy of seriously underwater properties that are also in foreclosure is continuing to decrease and is now at the lowest level we’ve seen since we began tracking that metric in the first quarter of 2012.”
The share of distressed properties — those in some stage of the foreclosure process — that were seriously underwater at the end of the second quarter was 34.4%, down from 35.1% in the first quarter of 2015 and down from 43.6% in the second quarter of 2014 to the lowest level since tracking began in the first quarter of 2012. Conversely, the share of foreclosures with positive equity increased to 42.4% in the second quarter, up slightly from 42.1% in the first quarter and up from 34.1% in the second quarter of 2014.
Click to enlarge
The universe of equity-rich mortgaged properties — those with at least 50% equity — decreased on a quarter-over-quarter basis for the second straight quarter, down to 10.9 million representing 19.6% of all properties with a mortgage at the end of the second quarter. That was down from 11.1 million representing 19.8% at the end of the first quarter and down from 11.3 million representing 20.3% at the end of the fourth quarter, but still up from 9.9 million representing 18.9% at the end of the second quarter of 2014.
“Although the number of equity rich homeowners with a mortgage has increased by 1 million compared to a year ago, that number dropped by nearly 300,000 between the end of 2014 and the middle of 2015,” Blomquist added. “The number of homeowners with a mortgage who have at least 20% equity has dropped by more than 900,000 during the past six months, indicating that homeowners who have gained substantial equity thanks to the housing price recovery over the past three years are taking advantage of that newfound equity.
“Some are leveraging that equity into a higher LTV refinance or a move-up purchase, some may be downsizing into an all-cash purchase and some may be cashing out of homeownership altogether. Those homeowners cashing out of homeownership altogether would explain why the nation’s overall homeownership rate continued to decline in the second quarter even as homeownership rates among millennials increased,” he said.
Major metro areas with the highest percentage of equity rich properties reflect areas of continued growth in home prices: San Jose, California (43.8%), San Francisco, California (38.3%), Honolulu, Hawaii (36.7%), Los Angeles, California (32%), New York (30.7%), Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (29.4%), Poughkeepsie, New York (28.0%), Oxnard, California (27.5%) and San Diego, California (26.9%).
“Over the past two years, the Seattle region has seen the percentage of homeowners who are seriously underwater drop by over 56%, one of the fastest and most impressive drops in the country,” said Matthew Gardner, chief economist at Windermere Real Estate, covering the Seattle market. “Usually a decline of this magnitude would suggest an uptick in the number of homes for sale, but unfortunately for Seattle, I don’t see this taking place. Many of these homeowners are simply too apprehensive or don’t have the financial capacity to move. But what we lose in new listings, we gain in overall market stability.”
Markets with a population greater than 500,000 with the highest percentage of seriously underwater properties in Q2 2015 were Lakeland, Florida, (28.5%), Cleveland, Ohio (28.2%), Las Vegas, Nevada (27.9%), Akron, Ohio (27.3%), Orlando, Florida (26.1%), Tampa, Florida (24.8%), Chicago, Illinois (24.8%), Palm Bay, Florida (24.4%) and Toledo, Ohio (24.3%).
Markets where the share of distressed properties — those in some stage of foreclosure — that were seriously underwater exceeded 50% in the first quarter of 2015 included Las Vegas, Nevada (57.7%), Lakeland, Florida (54.8%), Cleveland, Ohio (52.9%), Chicago, Illinois (52.5%), Tampa, Florida (51.7% ), Palm Bay, Florida (51.5%), and Orlando, Florida (51.2%).
“Many consumers in foreclosure don't understand the positive effects of the increased equity we are seeing across the Ohio markets, and the opportunities that this might bring in assisting them to avoid foreclosure,” said Michael Mahon, president at HER Realtors, covering the Cincinnati, Dayton and Columbus markets in Ohio. “Across much of Ohio, housing demand is driving increased prices and lower days on the market, contributing to positive equity growth. For homeowners facing troubled financial circumstances due to job loss, divorce, death in the family, or health concerns, the best advice would be to consult with a real estate agent early in the process.”
Those states with the highest% of distressed properties with positive equity included Colorado (72.0%), Alaska (69.8%), Texas (66.4%), Oklahoma (65.2%), and Nebraska (64.4%).
Major markets where the share of distressed properties with positive equity exceeded 60% included Denver, Colorado (83.7%), Austin, Texas (83.1percent), Honolulu, Hawaii (77.5%), San Jose, California (77%), Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (75.9%), Jackson Mississippi (75%), Nashville, Tennessee (69.3%) and Houston, Texas (69%).
“The strong South Florida price increases over the past few years have moved many homeowners from negative to positive equity. We would encourage the remaining distressed homeowners to ask for a Broker Price Opinion (BPO) regarding the value of their property — many may be surprised at their improving value,” said Mike Pappas, CEO and president of Keyes Company, covering the South Florida market.
“Many homeowners that found themselves upside down in their homes just a few years ago are finding that they are now in a much better position with equity to spare, based on the strong appreciation we have experienced over the last few years,” said Greg Smith, owner/broker at RE/MAX Alliance, covering the Denver market in Colorado. “When we look at other areas, such as Las Vegas, where homes seriously underwater have dropped by close to 50%, we see the strengthening of the economy as a whole provided by housing.”